Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Robert Shepherd's avatar

I very much agree about historical fiction— a related thing I find frustrating is when the fact we know what happens next hangs too much over the period itself.

I think that sometimes gives us in the setting’s future a sort of assurance I’m not sure we’ve really earned: seeing events in our own past as inevitable, when we don’t really know if they are.

But it also forces tragedy on people who have no idea their lives will become tragic; happy endings on people who are sure their futures are bleak. It’s a bit dehumanising to steal the unknowability of the future from people in your knowing way, I always think. Obviously the people are fictional in this case; I still get affronted on their behalf.

I really want someone to write a novel in 1816 or so with this in mind; it always sounds like a truly bleak moment to live through, but it’s not really seen that way when we have the ability to look back on it. “Winter came in summer and there wasn’t any food left!” I say, and people go “oh, because of the volcano.”

But they didn’t know that then. They didn’t know their hope for Queen Charlotte would never materialise, but the age that was coming would be named after a woman who was conceived as a result of Charlotte’s death. The Victorian era swamps their era, but even the word “Victorian” would have been baffling then. I’m rambling now

Oscar Jelley's avatar

One of my favourite Dickens paragraphs is this one from David Copperfield, for some reason:

6 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?